Aquarium Cleaning; Reasons & Methods, Frequency, Siphon Troubleshooting, more.

By Carl Strohmeyer
Updated 5/15/13

REASONS FOR WATER CHANGES (Freshwater OR marine):

The Reasons WHY are the MOST important aspects of why we clean and change our aquariums water.
All other aspects such as the 'How' you perform your aquarium cleaning and how often are all determined by “"the reasons why"!

What I mean by this previous statement is that the frequency, size, and methods of water changes are more subjective, however whatever method you choose, it should always come back to the objective of certain water parameters (which these too can vary as per fish kept).

It is also worth noting that most of these “Reasons for Water Changes” are inter related, so addressing one reason often has an affect on another; the results can be ignoring one "reason" often has a domino affect on other reasons".
As well testing for certain parameters is an objective way to determine whether a water change needs to be performed, as well as frequency and percentage.

(1)* Nitrate control- A nitrate level of 15-20 ppm or less is best for saltwater fish (10 ppm or less for Reef), 40-50 ppm or less for Freshwater with a Nitrate level of at least 15 ppm for planted FW aquariums, as plants need some bio available nitrates in the water column.
Use your nitrate level as a gauge (in an established aquarium) when to change your water. If your goal is to keep nitrates below 40 ppm, change water whenever nitrates reach this level.

Please note for marine aquarists; an average protein skimmer often cannot keep up with the organic waste output of an average stocked marine aquarium (although many modern Marine Protein Skimmers do a much better job than they did as recently as the 1990s). This means water changes along with other methods for organic removal and nitrate control are still usually necessary in marine aquariums with a protein skimmer.
There are obviously exceptions in a reef aquarium with large amounts of live rock and live sand, heavy plant or green algae growth, and light animal load. Even then added mineral elements need to be replaced in a closed aquarium system.

I often have told my clients/customers that Nitrate removal was an important reason for water changes, and utilizing vacuuming as a method of removing organic mulm is an effective way of maintaining low nitrates (especially in the absence of nitrogen reducing anaerobic filter bed).
Also as far as Nitrates, especially in marine aquariums, removing organic debris before it "cycles" via vacuuming (although this is where a protein skimmer comes in as well) is in my opinion, the main focus of nitrate removal via water change.

In freshwater aquariums (especially in the absence of a large amount of thriving plants), water changes using a gravel vacuum to remove ALL the organic mulm before it goes through the full nitrifying part of the nitrogen cycle plays a major part of controlling nitrates in a freshwater aquarium. The importance is amplified for tanks where Under Gravel Filters are employed (with these filters it is best to occasionally remove the lift tubes and siphon directly under the plate).

Test: Whatever number that exceeds what you establish as maximum nitrates such as 40 ppm may indicate a water change is needed.
As an example if you have gone several weeks without a water change and your nitrates are above the desired number, odds are this indicates more frequent water changes are needed. However if well thoroughly vacuumed 20% water changes are performed once per week and nitrates are still high, this may indicate a bio load too high for the aquarium filtration capacity and/or the need for additional nitrate control methods (of which there are many)

Please read these articles for more about Nitrates:
*“Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle”
*“Aquarium Nitrates; Methods for Control”
*“Hydrogen Sulfides/Nitrates”

(2)*GH and Electrolytes (positive mineral ions); this is related to the above point.
Water changes will often replenish necessary electrolytes when tap or well water are used. This is why RO water should ALWAYS be re-mineralized.

This is an important reason that is often missed in determining whether or not adequate methods, frequency, etc. of water changes are being utilized. If your aquarium mineral ions/electrolytes are low (see: Aquarium Chemistry), you are likely in need of a water change or should be employing products such as Wonder Shells, Aragamight, SeaChem Replenish and possibly aragonite. It should be noted that aragonite often will not respond rapidly enough to lower mineral levels as compared to Wonder Shells, Seachem Replenish or Equilibrium, or simple water changes with water rich in mineral cations (positive mineral ions/electrolytes).
Without adequate mineralization, your fish will suffer from poor osmoregulation and as well this will lower your Redox balance.

Test: a GH test is likely not going to be accurate for a water change as most residual minerals remain even when tests remain within desired parameters (See: Depletion of Positive Ions), that said any lower number of desired GH such as 150 ppm indicates either a need of more GH additives and/or a water change.

(3)*Ph and KH control- Maintaining a healthy pH & KH; ph levels have a tendency to drop from biological activity, while KH is the pH buffering ability of the water and that too can decrease between water changes.
KH is VERY important, and often when an aquarium keeper does not keep up with adequate cleaning schedules and add supplemental buffers, this can result in sudden spikes/drops in PH from a water change.
This is a major problem I have seen over the years in my maintenance business when calling on customers (not regular/contract maintenance clients) who seemed to always have problems with their aquariums and claimed cleaning their aquarium caused their problems, which of course is not true, rather it was maintenance of KH between cleanings and/or poor cleaning practices and frequency.

Maintaining a proper KH between cleanings is important. The use of Buffers, such as SeaChem Buffers will help with KH maintenance between water changes or to add to tap or well water prior to introduction to the aquarium with lower than desired KH (& pH)

It should be noted that when large volume of water changes are necessary for whatever reason, it is important to make sure that the new water added does not result in “roller coaster” pH reading. The osmotic stress on the fish caused by a sudden shift in pH can be harmful/deadly.
This consideration is especially important with fish such as Discus where a water change may cause a sudden spike in pH unless pH/KH adjusted new water, or partial or even 100% re-mineralized RO water is used.

Test: Unlike GH, carbonate buffers (KH) are often quickly depleted and any lower number under the desired KH target such as 100 ppm indicates the need for a water change and/or addition of buffers.
An unstable pH indicates similar actions.
Often if nitrates and other cleaning indicators are stable, the addition of KH buffers and GH mineral ion supplements are ALL that is necessary and a water change is NOT indicated.

(4)*Lowering of DOC & Removal of Organic Mulm (Sludge); DOC stands for Dissolved Organic Compounds (some refer to the ‘C’ in this abbreviation as Carbon which would relate to carbon based molecules). This is inter-related to some of the other reasons such Redox, Bio Load, Nitrates, even KH & pH (as often high DOC will have an end result of lowering pH).
This also includes removal of mulm/sludge from under-gravel filter plates (placing a siphon tube directly under a plate often has worked well for me) as well as removal of this mulm/sludge from canister and sometimes even wet/dry filters.

This is one of the more important reasons from my years of experience as well as some controlled tests since DOC in the water column and Organic Mulm/Sludge under the gravel, decorations, rocks, etc. can have a profound effect on so many aspects of aquarium health such as the previously noted Nitrates, Redox, and even opportunistic diseases, in particular Saprolegnia/Fungus and Aeromonas.

This is achieved two ways in cleanings:
* Simply removing water on a regular basis removes DOC from the water column.

* The second aspect is surprisingly misunderstood, even by experienced aquarists and that is by thorough vacuuming of organic mulm, you remove a major cause/source of DOC.

A Vortex Diatom Filter can aid in removal of Organic Mulm/Sludge, although the gravel must be constantly stirred to make this device fully effective. However not only is this not usually possible, but this is also much more stressful to fish (I have used Diatom filters for years and they are still excellent devices when used properly).

Another device, the electric (battery powered) “Bag” vacuums are not nearly as efficient as Diatom Filters. These use a bag that does not even trap 25% of the DOC causing mulm that a true micron filter can, my tests measuring Nitrates, KH, & Redox show this.
An exception to this would be the Eheim Sludge Remover Battery Vacuum, as it uses a much better reusable micron filter than the older style “Bag” battery Vacuums.
Although the Eheim Battery Vacuum is not as effective to Diatom Filters, these devices make up for it in vastly less agitation of the substrate into the water column and thus much less stress on the fish

I should be noted that none of these devices still take the place of a water change in my experience/tests.

Test: Similar test to Nitrates, so besides visual indicators; high amounts of DOC & mulm will generally be indicated in rising nitrates, unstable pH, and dropping KH.

(5)*Removal of harmful elements; There are many toxins that can be introduced, airborne or in other ways enter the aquarium that are not easily measured.
Carbon may help with this as well, but should not be over used.

Test: No applicable test, however if carbon is not affective or known toxins have been introduced by accident or for whatever reason to the aquarium; a water change is a must (possible a large water change at that)

(6)*Control of Bio Load; Although an aquarium cleaning/water change is not the long term answer to an over crowded, over fed, and under filtered aquarium; cleanings are certainly necessary to lower your bio load by removal of decaying organics in your gravel, under décor, and often in under maintained filters as well.
A common symptom of a high organic load is rapidly dropping pH and KH as well as sighting of Detritus Worms during cleanings or when oxygen levels drop (these worms will rise to the surface when oxygen levels are low seeking oxygen). These Worms are often misidentified as Planaria by many here on the internet, however they are not Planaria (which can be present too). For more on this subject, please read this article: Trematodes and Nematodes/ Detritus Worms

(7)*Redox Potential ; this is an often unknown parameter to many aquarists but is actually quite important, especially with newer research I have uncovered. That said most freshwater aquarists usually do not need to worry about this if water changes and other aspects of good aquatic husbandry are observed (for marine aquariums this is even more important and is often not as easily maintained). However, I would recommend learning more about this parameter if you are a serious aquarist, and the purchase of a Redox meter if you can afford one (they sell for over $200) may be a useful tool as well.

Test: A Redox Meter can be used, but Redox balance is not readily determined even by a Redox Meter since the reading would and SHOULD vary depending upon aquarium conditions; such as a more oxidizing state when high bio loads and decomposition are present or a lower Redox for reduction when the aquarium is stable (otherwise a continued high redox can result in depletion of fish' ability to use mineral cations resulting in lower immunity)

(8)* Removal of waste before it can go thru the Nitrogen Cycle. This is related to other aspects/reason for water changes, although here I specifically mean the removal nitrogenous waste molecules in the water column that begin with ammonia, to nitrites and then end up as nitrates.
Water changes can lower these nitrogenous molecules (ammonia, etc.) prior to the cycling process thus resulting on lower nitrates as noted in section #1.

As well in tanks that have been medicated, especially with gram positive medications such as Erythromycin a water change lowers pressure on a damaged or even destroyed bio filter and thus removes dangerous ammonia ions.
Devices such as Protein Skimmers (marine tanks only) can be an aid to this process as well.
Please see this article for vastly more on this subject: The Nitrogen Cycle..

Test: Again, similar test to Nitrates (& pH/KH), so besides visual indicators; high amounts of wastes (such as fecal matters) will generally be indicated in rising nitrates, unstable pH, and dropping KH.
Poor Filtration may also be indicated.

(9)* Control of algae growth; this aspect is often missed, yet is very basic. Water changes (assuming replacement with water that has natural balanced nutrients) will generally return the proper balances of Macro nutrients (PO4, NO3, K) to a freshwater tank for plants to out compete algae. In saltwater excess nutrients are removed, again allowing for less algae growth.

Test: No applicable test

(10)* Rinsing of bio-sponges, media, etc. in used aquarium or de-chlorinated tap water (generally not straight tap water). This includes sponge filters, bio balls, and ceramic media in canister filters (canister filters need to be cleaned more often than many aquarists think due to nitrate producing and KH reducing mulm buildup).
Occasionally I do not use de-chlorinated tap water or used aquarium water to rinse all parts of a canister filter such as mechanical filtration poly pads, or even some sponges. The reason is if there is more than adequate amounts on ammonia/nitrite reducing nitrifying bacteria and you aquarium nitrates are quite high, this can indicate your aerobic nitrifying filter media has become a "nitrate factory" (I always leave at least the ceramic, volcanic rock, SeaChem Matrix or other bio media rinsed in only de-chlorinated water so as to preserve nitrifying or de-nitrifying bacteria behind).

As well either at the time of water change or a midway point (or similar) between water changes, chemical filter products such as Carbon or SeaChem Purigen should be changed.

Rinsing of filter media is not quite a “reason for water change” (more a reason for maintenance/cleaning), but is certainly a part of regular tank maintenance that should not be ignored.

(11)* Disease eradication; changing water for disease eradication may not solve the problem, but may be a step towards the problem when done in conjunction with medications/treatments (even bleachings and subsequent aquarium re-starts).
Since this is not really the scope (purpose) of this article, please see this article (in the Cleanliness section) where I give some water change examples for disease/parasite problems:
“Aquarium Disease Prevention”

I will also note that water changes are important prior to each treatment with aquatic medications so as to lower medication absorbing DOC and “spent” medications themselves so as to render more effective treatments.
See: “Aquarium Medications”

Test: No applicable test, although small water changes after EVERY treatment and a larger water change after finishing treatment is strongly recommended so as to lower medication absorbing compounds in the water column.

* All these reasons are based on 30+ years of professional aquarium maintenance with some of the largest accounts in Los Angeles, CA
The above section is the most objective aspect of this article, everything that follows is more subjective and utilizing what ever cleaning method, frequency, or combinations there of are all determined by achieving that above criteria which admittedly is not all as important as each other, however I would consider points 1-8 essential based on both experience and scientifically controlled tests/studies.

Summary of "Reasons for Water Changes;"

My point is that a 25% water change every 2-4 weeks may be all that is required to maintain correct water parameters due to excellent filtration, nitrate removal methods, and chemistry husbandry by one aquarist but not adequate for another aquarist due to a high bio load, lesser filtration, less than stable water parameters, etc.!
Or one aquarist may do fine with the German or flow through method while another may fail and the use of products such as the Aquarium Cleaning Machine or Eheim Sludge Remover may be necessary for DOC control.

HOWEVER, if your aquarium requires 100% water changes every week to maintain stable pH, nitrate, ammonia, etc; My experience with such aquariums has shown these problems:
*Poor chemistry maintenance procedures
See: Aquarium Chemistry & Use of RO or Water Softener in Aquarium

*A Nitrogen Cycle that is not properly established
See: Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle

*Inadequate Filtration
See: Aquarium Filtration & Aquarium Filter Media, Material; Mechanical, Bio, Chemical

*Poor Redox Balance (including lack of UV Sterilization in aquariums where it can aid in improving this parameter
See: Aquarium Redox Balance

*Poor Cleaning Methods
See further in this article

*Too High a bio load
Related to Nitrogen Cycle, Also see Freshwater Basics
Back To Top

FREQUENCY (& volume of water change);

Use these factors to determine frequency (& possibly volume/size).
Keep in mind that this is a subject that is mostly dependent upon many objective factors of water parameters (as with "Reasons").

*Type of fish, such as fish that naturally produce more waste (partly
due to the type of food they eat) such as goldfish where one fish per 8+
gallons of water is better. Also a large and dirty fish such as an Oscar is another good example.

*Filtration, a well filtered aquarium (good bio filtration, good mechanical filtration, and good circulation) with multiple filters is important.

*Well maintained water chemistry (including a stable kH and Redox)

*After proper feeding, filtration (including choice of filter media) good cleaning routines, as a starting point; 10-20% water changes with a gravel vacuum once per week or two is suggested.

If after all these are checked off and you still have nitrates that struggle to stay below 40-50 ppm (20 ppm for saltwater), you probably need to change more water or increase frequency and/or efficiency (especially if there are live plants!). Also consideration into other Nitrate Control Methods should be undertaken.

Also a kH and pH that starts out at desired levels, but then drops quickly after water changes and/or the need for higher than normal recommended KH Buffers can indicate ineffective cleaning routines (as well as other problems such as mulm buildup).

*Caution should be used with larger volume water changes (especially over 50%) so as to not cause pH spikes either up or down, as well dramatic changes in other parameters as well.
I would simply caution that these pH swings can cause considerable osmotic shock to fish during larger water changes if the “new” water is not correctly adjusted for pH/KH.

The use of large water changes to make up for poor aquatic management including a lack of an established Nitrogen Cycle should not be done.

My personal and professional experience has shown that rather than employ large water changes that some may use for sensitive fish such as Discus, I would recommend the use of an Eheim Sludge Remover Battery Gravel Vacuum in between water changes to remove excess organic waste/sludge/mulm.

In the case of high ammonia/nitrites: it is noteworthy that if your aquarium has copious amounts of decomposition in the absence of correct KH Buffers it likely will result in a low pH. A pH under 6.5 will convert much of your aquarium ammonia to non toxic NH4 all the while slowing the nitrogen cycle and thus natural removal of ammonia.
So a sudden large water change that changes the pH, can and often will result in more toxic NH3 ammonia. This is vicious cycle of pH swings and high ammonia I have observed in particular with Betta bowls without any bio media.
See: Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle; High Ammonia for more.

In the case of bowls, finding methods to alleviate large water changes that can induce pH, osmotic, or oxidative stress is suggested.
This would include a small sponge filter, use of Matrix in small containers or simply on the bottom of the bowl, and/or Wonder Shells (for continuous positive mineral ion replacement).

A flow-through water change system (see the methods section later in the article) is another answer to this question/potential problem of large water changes.

Simply put from my experience AND controlled tests NO Aquarium or bowl should have a 100% water change even for high ammonia other than if poisons (such as roach spray) are accidentally added.
Back To Top

AQUARIUM CLEANING BASICS:

For an established, healthy aquarium I recommend changing 10-20% of your aquarium water once per week (best) or at least 25%+ once per month. With good filtration and plants (live rock in marine aquaria), you often can go longer than once per week. Use a de-chlorinator such as Start Right or Prime (Prime also detoxifies ammonia and nitrites) while refilling your aquarium if tap water is used. All de-chlorinators work instantly usually comprised of Sodium Thiosulfate.

Please note:
Contrary to some information thrown around without much research, vacuuming the layers of gravel that contain aerobic (nitrifying) bacteria will NOT destroy the bacterial colonies as research (that really is not that new) has shown these bacteria to secrete a glue like substance to the media they cling to and a gravel vacuum will NOT dislodge these bacteria.
See this article about the aquarium nitrogen cycle: NITROGEN CYCLE AND AQUARIUM CYCLING; How the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle Works

STEPS:

* Unplug your heater so that it will not crack if the water level drops more than 1/3 of the way down the heater. This is best done 20 minutes before you begin changing water. Make sure and plug the heater back in after adding water

*Make sure and wipe down the sides of the aquarium with an aquarium scrubber that is used ONLY for the aquarium to avoid contamination. Try and remove unsightly algae and especially any slime or mold (rinse this off in a sink)

*Use this time to change filter media that NEEDS changing, do NOT go overboard and change all media or you risk destroying your aquarium’s bacterial colonies needed for removal of ammonia, nitrites, etc. (see this article: NITROGEN CYCLE AND AQUARIUM CYCLING; How the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle Works ). HOB filters should have a second filter cartridge either in the filter or in the water column of the aquarium to allow for bacteria to form on this new cartridge before replacing the old one. If your HOB Filter has a sponge, bio grid or bio sponge (such as a VitaLife HOB filter , or bio wheel; you only need to rinse these off in de-chlorinated tap or used tank water and there is no need to prepare a second cartridge before changing the old one. For more about aquarium filters, please read this article:
Aquarium Filtration and Filters .

*At this point you should change your water using a gravel vacuum, siphon, or similar method.

*For more about methods of water change and procedures to refill your aquarium, please read further in this article under procedure.

METHODS FOR WATER CHANGE:

BASIC:
For cleaning your aquarium (freshwater or saltwater) a Gravel Vacuum attached to a siphon or re-circulating filter works best. These vacuums are quite easy to use; simply push the bell of the vacuum into the gravel and quickly back out. If you are having problems with sucking gravel into the siphon hose, try kinking the hose with your other hand to slow the out flow to keep gravel from being sucked up.
Make sure and lift ornaments out of the way and vacuum in as many dead spots as possible. It is important to get as much of this organic “mulm” out of the aquarium as possible as this is what leads to higher nitrates, ph crashes (due to nitric acid production during decay), and resulting in poor KH levels.
(Please click on picture to enlarge)

Starting the Gravel Vacuum is usually quite simple (depending upon the brand though). With the Lees, simply placing the end of the hose (water exhaust) into a bucket, the turning the “bell” of the vacuum into the tank and rotating it to remove air, then moving the vacuum bell up & down with quick actions will allow the quick start valve to start the siphon. If this valve breaks (the valve rarely lasts as long as the vacuum) or you have a vacuum without this feature, a quick “suck” on the end of the tube (below tank level) into the bucket should start the siphon with little effort.

Tips to starting a basic gravel vacuum:
*Using a gravel vacuum such as the Lees Gravel Vacuum with a start valve and shaking it up and down a few times
*Filling the bell with water while plugging the small end then placing the bell quickly into the water
*A quick suck (not as nasty as it sounds if done quickly)
*Attaching to a long hose and running water in to the hose from a faucet, then disconnecting allowing gravity to drain out the door (into a garden or even a toilet), this is the method I used most for my large aquariums, especially in offices I maintained in my service business. This applies to Pythons and similar

Further Siphon Tips (including attached to hose):
• If your vacuum siphon does not start easily, this may mean that you have some water in the tubing that is blocking the siphon; ANY amount of water in the siphon tube can block the siphon from starting (even a tablespoon), especially when the tube has less vertical distance and more horizontal distance to where the water is exhausted to (bucket, garden, toilet, etc.). Make sure to evacuate ALL water prior to attempting to start a siphon.
• If your vacuum is connected to a hose or longer tubing, it is even more important to evacuate all water from this hose prior to starting the siphon. I recommend carefully rolling up the hose, keeping the end lower than the rest of the hose while all water is removed. You should store all hoes this way too for quicker siphon start in the future.
• If you fail in the first attempt to start a siphon with a long hose attached, you may end up with water in the hose that will block future attempts, so starting over by making sure all water is evacuated will save you much frustration.
Otherwise another method of starting a siphon with a long hose attached is to attach the female end of the hose to a faucet and turn on the faucet until all “bubbles” are blown out through the vacuum bell into the tank. Once this is done, simply detaching the hose from the faucet will immediately start the siphon.
Caution should be used in this second method that the vacuum bell is securely placed under the water and that you do not turn the hose on with too much force, otherwise this may result in the vacuum bell “jumping” out of the tank and making quite the mess or at the least the bell not staying under the surface of the water resulting in a failed siphon attempt.
• Finally attaching the hose to a “siphon pump” at either a sink or the faucet makes draining the tank (starting a siphon) quite easy, however this also wastes much water (although you can detach the siphon pump after starting the siphon if the exhaust from the hose is below the water level of the tank).
Back To Top

DIY Gravel Vacuum System (Python Style)

You can make a DIY Super Gravel Vacuum using 25' to 50' lengths of 5/8" ID Aquarium Tubing OR a sterile 5/8" garden hose (a sterile RV water hose is perfect), a Lees 10" Gravel Vacuum, some duct tape for wrapping around the end of the Vacuum tubing for a better fit, A Lees or Python Water Pump and faucet adapter.

(please click the picture above/left to go to a page with a larger picture).

You can also add in this Valve kit to splice into your standard vacuum to make attachment to the garden hose much easier. This kit also includes a valve for flow control. I recommend this additional part for a 100% professional Gravel Vacuum System.

I recommend removing the Gravel Vacuum when filling and using a suction cup attached to the hose to secure it to the inside of the aquarium when filling (although it works fine with water returning thru the gravel vacuum, just make sure the whole vacuum is in the water before filling just in case the end becomes detached).

If the faucet adapter pump fits poorly to your sink/utility faucet, resulting in a messy spray of water, I recommend to simply wrap a small towel or similar around the faucet adapter, this will allow the water to drip harmlessly into the sink.

BOWLS OR SIMILAR:

A mistake I have documented in several controlled tests is the "over cleaning" of bowls; meaning changing 100% of the water and scrubbing, sterilizing the bowl prior to reintroducing the fish (usually a Betta).

In these tests I documented an ammonia level as high as 2 ppm in as soon as 1 day after such a cleaning practice.

Better is a water change of 50% along with a simple wiping and rinsing of any substrate (such as marbles) and decor.
Better yet is to use a small sponge filter, Matrix (or similar) as a substrate, or use Matrix or similar in small medicine bottle that is only mildly rinsed with old bowl or de-chlorinated water. This would allow for at least some bio filtration and important bio stability to your small tank/bowl.

See the picture above/left for Matrix used in medicine bottles for a betta bowl

PLANTED AQUARIUM:
If you have a planted aquarium, I recommend #00 sand (3-5 cm) mixed with SeaChem Flourite, Eco-Complete, laterite or conditioned soil with #3 gravel (2-3 cm) on top; you should vacuum the sand as little as possible (or at least below the top ½ inch layer of #3 gravel), as this will tend to be sucked all the way thru the vacuum, and this will also disturb the natural aerobic and symbiotic anaerobic filtration going on in the substrate being performed by the plant roots and nearby bacteria (although areas of substrate without plants can be vacuumed more deeply).
If the sand must be vacuumed, very gently push the bell of the vacuum into the sand and quickly back out, kinking the hose with your other hand to slow the out flow to keep sand and/or plant substrate from being sucked up.

This point is often lost by some aquarists, based on some very misinformed & even rude comments I have read including on my YouTube cleaning video (most of the rude have been removed too). In fact in a planted aquarium it is NORMAL to have very dirty appearing gravel when vacuumed, but one should not expect or try and achieve gravel appears 100% "clean" when vacuumed as this is not necessarily an indictor of tank healthy and in fact by trying to achieve this you end up with poor substrate nutrient levels for your plants and poor de-nitrification resulting in high nitrates. See the German method below.

REEF:
If you have a reef or Nano Reef aquarium with live sand, vacuum very gently as I described for planted aquariums and do not push the bell of the vacuum down into the sand more than ½” to ¾” so as to not add oxygen to anaerobic (de-nitrifying bacteria). By maintaining a 1/2" layer of #3 crushed coral on top of a fine deep sand bed it traps organic waste particles better and allows easier vacuuming of the top layer of gravel/sand.
I will occasionally push the vacuum bell deeper into the sand in alternating areas of the aquarium sand looking for build up of organic debris/mulm and also to prevent sulfur reduction resulting in hydrogen sulfide production.
The idea is to vacuum most of the waste off the upper layer of gravel while occasionally pushing the bell into the sad allowing just enough oxygen and nitrates to penetrate so as to prevent sulfur reduction. What you want to look for is areas of “black mold” in the sand bed, which is actually not mold but indicative of hydrogen sulfide production vie sulfur reduction.

This method is also important for a FOWLR aquarium (fish only with live rock) that employs sand for de-nitrification.

GERMAN METHOD:
This method is really a variance of the freshwater planted aquarium cleaning method in my opinion;
In some successful aquarium keeping traditions (especially in Germany), no vacuuming is performed. Water is simply siphoned out of the aquarium and new water is carefully added back in. For this method to be successful in fresh water aquariums, you need a healthy growth of plants, good lighting, a thin layer of sand just enough to cover plant roots (not gravel). Good aerobic AND anaerobic filtration (that is nitrogen reducing, NOT sulfur reducing which would produce hydrogen sulfides) is also a must.
This method can also be employed in part with other methods such as partial vacuum cleanings in certain areas as I do in my planted aquariums.

FLOW THROUGH METHOD
This method is the aquarium version of the “spring fed pond, or pond over flow method” that I use in ponds (this is especially useful for delicate fish such as Discus or German Rams, but this must be done correctly as well for these fish to be successful).

Commonly this method is set up in ware house type setting, but can be single aquariums as well. With this method, you would have a small drain right at the surface of the aquarium water line (usually with a strainer to prevent fish form accidentally getting in).
Water is added either from a large holding tank via a slow rate water pump or directly from the tap or well water lines. If added directly from tap water, your municipal water company must NOT use chloramines as these are not readily removed and remain in the aquarium for long periods of time, where as chlorine in municipal tap water is not generally a problem if added at a rate of less than 10-20% per day, provided you have good aeration and possible some carbon filtration as well.
Personally I recommend the use of holding tank or large drum, as chlorine may not be the only issue, such as low KH, pH or similar (even with well water). With the holding tank you can add buffers and minerals such as a Wonder Shell. This method can even be employed with marine aquariums, however this definitely necessitates a holding tank for clean/mixed saltwater.
Another variation on this method is much more simple or basic and that is (if you have time) to simply “skim” off a total of 10% of your water per day at varying intervals.

One advantage of this method (among a few) is that you will often have very health and balanced Redox.

Which ever way you employ this method, if your tank has gravel or does not employ healthy de-nitrification (whether in a deep sand bed for marine aquariums or planted freshwater) you should still vacuum at intervals needed to keep water parameters to the desired levels of the fish you are keeping.

Combined Methods
Since “HOW” (method used) you clean you aquarium as well as “FREQENCY” are subjective, while “WHY” (desired water parameters) is more objective you can often employ multiple methods of cleaning (as I do) and achieve excellent results as that is really the bottom line and those who will tell you that there way is the only way is often someone you do not want to get aquatic advice from. I recommend the method or methods that achieve what is outlined at the very beginning of this article and that is “The reasons for a Water Change/Cleanings”. As long as these points are met, what ever method or combination is working for you is good.

I vary this from client to client do to many variables such as bio load, feeding habits, filtrations, even frequency of visits.
For personal tanks I am currently using some of the German/Planted tank method along with the over flow/skimming method, vacuuming and finally the use of the Aquarium Cleaning Machine to lower DOC (this is an exceptional tool for high bio load tanks in particular).
Back To Top

PROCEDURE and REFILL (Continued):

You can drain this water into a bucket or attach the siphon to a long hose and drain it outside or into a toilet using gravity.
There are other products that hook on to the sink, but these are over rated in my opinion and waste water. It is simpler to just get a long hose and get an adapter and attach your hose to the sink to fill, but drain your water into a garden where it will do some good (unless it is saltwater of course). If you do need this type of product you can make a DIY model with a Lee’s Gravel Vac, a garden hose, a faucet adapter from a local Hardware Store, and a water bed pump/drain. Lee’s also makes one that is less expensive than the Python and is exactly the same.

I prefer to leave the fish in during this process, as I feel more stress is added to the fish removing them and then placing the fish back in new water conditions that the fish are not accustomed to (controlled experiments I performed in the late 70s confirmed that removal for cleaning is much more stressful to fish).
Add water back slowly, and if tap water is used make sure the temperature is similar to the aquarium water already present in the aquarium, you can generally safely add warm tap water to correct this. Although in the Marine aquariums I maintained, I brought my own water and it was invariably colder than the aquarium, but this does not present as much of a problem as many think. If you do some math; Say your aquarium is 78 F and you add 20% water back that is 68 F, that is 1/5th the volume, so 1/5th of a 10 F difference is only 2 F.

As well make sure your new water does not adjust the pH more than .2 on the logarithmic pH scale. For instance a tank with a pH of 7.0 that has a 25% water change should not have water more than 7.8 or less than 6.2 added to it quickly.

Do not add RO (Reverse Osmosis) water directly (other than topping off for evaporation) until water is re-mineralized and buffered correctly.
If blended tap and RO water is used, use of a water conditioner and at least some mineral electrolyte replenisher is highly suggested so as to prevent Redox and/or oxidative stress.
I should note that many aquarium maintenance professionals do not add any aquarium conditioners for water changes under 20% (or even more) in established tanks. This is certainly acceptable as a healthy/established aquarium generally will not have a problem with the small amount of chlorine that might be introduced, generally breaking it down more quickly than any harm can come to the fish in these diluted amounts.
That said I respectfully do not agree with this for the reasons that the use of many conditioners such as Prime also help add electrolytes and balance Redox (albeit temporarily) which allows for less oxidative stress on the fish and further aids in the water quality improvement a water change provides.
As well if chloramines are present in your municipal water supply the use of a top notch water conditioner such as Prime or Amquel Plus is a must since chloramines are much more stable and do not decay from water agitation, plus chloramines contain toxic ammonia.
Please see this article for more about Chloramines:
Aquarium Answers; Chloramines in Tap Water

*What is more important is adding a de-chlorinator to your tap water (if tap water is used) WHILE the water is being added if you are filling via a hose, DIY Python, or similar device. I prefer to use the full strength of the water conditioner as per aquarium size so as to obtain all the benefits of reducers, electrolytes, etc. of your water conditioner. I will add approximately 25%-50% of the conditioner prior to start of the refill with the rest added incrementally as I fill.
*If using a bucket, I add the water conditioner per each bucket prior to adding each bucket back to the aquarium. I also recommend adding further water conditioner as per the complete tank volume after bucket(s) are added to obtain all the benefits of the water conditioner as noted previously (depending upon conditioner used, as product such as “API Tap Water Conditioner” only remove chlorine and provide no other benefits)

I often use Start Right, this product removes chlorine (and the chlorine ions attached ammonia in chloramines), removes heavy metals, and very importantly naturally stimulates the slime coat in fish vs. products that drop an artificial “wad” of slime into the aquarium that generally sinks to the bottom anyway.
Otherwise I prefer/recommend Prime or similar products such as Amquel (newer Amquel Plus is more similar to Prime), although in my experience Prime is a superior product over Amquel, please see this article: Aquarium and Pond Answers; Water Conditioners .

Prime or Amquel Plus is a must for new tanks or tanks with ammonia or nitrite problems.
Prime will bind ammonia into non-toxic ammonium (NH4) and neutralize nitrites as well as remove chlorine and chloramines. However this is not a replacement for a properly cycled aquarium.
Back To Top
Cleaning Machines/ Diatoms
A relatively new device that performs both water removal and recirculation thru a micron filter cartridge that is easily cleaned is the Aquarium Cleaning Machine. This device uses a protected magnet-drive motor to remove or re-circulate your water thru a filter (or both).
For freshwater aquariums this device is can be helpful, especially for those with larger or multiple aquariums. I saves time but more importantly it allows for a much better cleaning while at the same time leaving nitrifying bacteria behind (which often gets stripped in large conventional cleanings in tanks with high bio loads).

Sadly though, the company that owns the patent/builds this product has ceased production and due to mismanagement and poor customer service likely will not be available again.

Vortex Diatoms; although not commonly used still can have their place for cleaning established aquariums with high bio loads, however with the advent of the aquarium cleaning machine which performs similar functions WITHOUT the need to stir up the tank as much and add stress to the fish by doing so, these have pretty much gone the way of the dinosaurs IMO.

Sludge Remover Vacuums; these devices are not as powerful or as efficient as a Vortex Diatom, however these do not stir up the water (which can stress fish) as much as a Diatom Cleaning Filter. The Eheim Sludge Remover Battery Vacuum is more efficient than most battery vacuums with a micron filter versus a bag as most “cheapie” battery sludge vacuums utilize.
However neither these devices nor the Diatom Filter actually perform necessary water changes (the Aquarium Cleaning Machine can perform the function water changes as well as being the best re-circulating cleaning filter available), that said a good sludge remover vacuum such as the Eheim is an excellent way to remove organic mulm or rotting waste in between water changes, especially for smaller aquariums or aquarium keepers on a budget where the products such as the Aquarium Cleaning Machine are simply not an option.
Back To Top

VIDEO:

Here is my NEW basic Aquarium Vacuum/Siphon cleaning demonstration that I made a video for (with some added help this time). I hope this is better about demonstrating vacuuming basics (making videos is not a talent of mine).
Please note that this is a Planted aquarium where much plant grower substrate is used, along with partial use of the “German Cleaning Method” so the appearance of an extra dirty aquarium is normal, but what counts is water parameters as stated earlier in this article (which are A+).

For more aquarium information and articles (pond too), please visit this site:

Back To Top